Sokada

Why Is My Competitor Ranking Above Me on Google?

Why is your competitor ranking above you on Google? How Google orders local and organic results, and how to compare your business with theirs.

Author Jaida

I look after a bit of everything: planning and creating social content, sparking blog ideas, polishing copy, updating websites and generally making sure everything we publish feels on-brand and actually does a job.

Jaida

If you have searched for your own service and found a competitor sitting above you, the usual answer to “why is my competitor ranking above me on Google?” is that Google sees their business as the better match for that search. At Sokada, a web design and digital marketing agency in Heathfield, we break that down into a few areas you can check. These are distance, your Google Business Profile, reviews, how well your page matches the search, links from other websites and how easy your site is to use.

Check You Are Seeing What Your Customers See.

Your own search results are not always the same as your customers’ results.

Google says results can differ from person to person because of the time of the search, the searcher’s location, their language, the device they are using and, for people signed in to Google, personalisation based on their search history.

So the order you see at your desk may not be the order someone sees on their phone across town.

Search in a private browser window, which stops your own search history shaping what you see, and try it on a phone as well as a computer. Then look at Google Search Console, which shows the searches your website appears for and the average position it holds across real searches.

Not getting enough enquiries?

Book a free audit and we’ll spend 30 minutes going through your website, telling you exactly what’s holding it back and what we’d do to fix it.

Book your free audit

What our clients have to say.

Real feedback from satisfied customers who’ve experienced first-hand how our solutions have made a difference.

  • I recommend Sokada for any social media and SEO help

    As I write this Google Review for Jude at Sokada it is with a little chuckle, because it was with setting up my own Google My Business page that Jude helped. She had explained how important it is for a business to have that presence. But, setting it up was beyond me. Jude took me by the hand and made every step of setting up my profile easy. I recommend Sokada for any social media and SEO help your business needs.

    Alison Purves International Business Developer with Forever The Aloe Vera Company
  • Cannot recommend Julian and the whole team at Sokada. Their knowledge and advice on websites and digital marketing is second to none and they will always give you the best and most honest advice.

    Danielle Hemming

Map Results and Website Results Work Differently.

For local searches, Google often shows a set of businesses on a map above the main results. Those positions come from your Google Business Profile, not only your website.

Google says local results are mainly based on three things.

  • Relevance, how well a Business Profile matches what someone is searching for
  • Distance, how far each business is from the person searching
  • Prominence, how well known a business is, based partly on links from other websites and its reviews

Distance is the one you cannot change. If your competitor is closer to the person searching, that alone can put them above you.

The rest is within your control. Google recommends verifying your business, keeping your details complete and accurate, including your hours and category, adding photos and replying to reviews. It also says more reviews and positive ratings can help your local ranking.

What you cannot do is pay for it. Google states there is no way to request or pay for a better local ranking.

Their Page May Match the Search More Closely.

For the main results, Google says its systems first work out the meaning behind a search, then look for content that is relevant to it. The most basic sign of relevance, according to Google, is a page containing the same keywords as the search.

So look at the page that is beating you, rather than their homepage.

Does it have a page dedicated to the exact service and area that was searched for? Does the page title use the words your customers use? Do the headings and opening paragraph make it clear what the page is about?

If they have a full page about one service in one town, and you mention that service in a list on your homepage, their page is the closer match. A well-written landing page for each main service is often the fix.

Not getting enough enquiries?

Book a free audit and we’ll spend 30 minutes going through your website, telling you exactly what’s holding it back and what we’d do to fix it.

Book your free audit

Case studies.

Behind every one of these is a business owner who was frustrated, not getting enough enquiries, and needed someone to actually sort it. We’re proud of every single one.

All case studies

Blackstock Country Estate

+188% Increase in enquiries YTD vs Last Year

They May Show More Signs of Trust.

Google says it looks for content that shows expertise, authoritativeness and trustworthiness, and one of the signals it names is when other prominent websites link to a page.

Compare what sits behind their website with what sits behind yours. Are local organisations, trade bodies, suppliers or news sites linking to them? Do they show real reviews, case studies, named people and clear contact details?

Our guide on what makes a high quality backlink explains which links are worth having and which are not.

Their Website May Be Easier to Use.

Google says that when other things are roughly equal, content people find more accessible may perform better, and it gives mobile-friendliness and loading speed as examples.

Open both websites on your phone. Notice which one loads faster, which is easier to read and which makes it simpler to call or send an enquiry.

You can also run both through Google’s free PageSpeed Insights tool to compare how each performs. If yours is slow or awkward on a phone, the way it was built may be holding it back.

Paying for Ads Does Not Change Organic Rankings.

If your competitor appears above you with a Sponsored label, that is an advert, not an organic ranking.

Google says advertisers do not receive special treatment in its organic results and that nobody can pay to rank higher. Ads are a separate, paid placement, so your competitor’s ad spend does not lift their organic position, and running your own ads will not lift yours.

If you are thinking about adverts as well, our post on how much a small business should spend on Google Ads is a sensible place to start.

Not getting enough enquiries?

Book a free audit and we’ll spend 30 minutes going through your website, telling you exactly what’s holding it back and what we’d do to fix it.

Book your free audit

The Same Applies in AI Answers.

More people now see an AI-generated answer before the list of links. Google says its generative AI features in Search are built on the same core ranking and quality systems as the rest of Search.

That means the same things help. Google points to original, useful content written from your own knowledge and experience, a website it can crawl and index, a good page experience and an up-to-date Google Business Profile. It also says you do not need special files such as llms.txt to appear in its AI features.

If a competitor is being mentioned in AI answers and you are not, it usually comes back to the same gaps covered above. Our post on the difference between SEO, AEO and GEO explains how the three fit together.

How to Compare Your Business With Theirs.

Work through these checks, side by side, for the search you care about most.

  • Search for it in a private window, on a phone and on a computer
  • Note whether they are beating you in the map results, the main results or both
  • Compare both Google Business Profiles, the category, the details, the photos and the reviews
  • Compare the page that ranks with your page for the same service
  • Look at who links to their website and who links to yours
  • Test both websites on a phone and in PageSpeed Insights
  • Check Search Console to see which of your pages appear for that search

The biggest gap is usually the best place to start.

So Why Is Your Competitor Ranking Above You?

Why is my competitor ranking above me on Google? Most of the time it comes down to a handful of things, a page that matches the search more closely, a stronger Google Business Profile, more signs of trust or a website that is easier to use. Apart from distance, most of it is within your control, and none of it can be bought.

At Sokada our SEO services look at all of these together, alongside the website itself, with one aim, more enquiries.

If a competitor keeps appearing above you, book a free audit and Julian will go through your website and SEO with you on a Zoom call and talk you through what is holding you back.

You can also call us on 01435 817226 or get in touch with the team.

Not getting enough enquiries?

Book a free audit and we’ll spend 30 minutes going through your website, telling you exactly what’s holding it back and what we’d do to fix it.

30 years
Building websites that actually get results
3x More Enquiries
Average increase for clients in their first six months

Not getting enough enquiries?

We'll spend 30 minutes going through your website, telling you exactly what's holding it back and what we'd do to fix it.

Book your free audit
97%
Of our clients see improved search visibility within 90 days
1-in-3
New clients come to us through referrals from existing clients